If you've been following reviews of works in the Critiques Board, you might have noticed my in depth critique of Fox's Compilation entry. I plan on making this my normal approach to reviewing works. It's a long process, but I think it will produce a better quality of information for the author to use.
If you'd like to use the same style of critique, here's where I got my checklist:
How to Critique FictionRead sections 1-3 (the checklist is section 2) for a good in-depth method. If quick-and-dirty is your style, then this method isn't for you.
Just an FYI.
More reviews are coming...I'm just a little short on time...
J.